Custom vs. Production Homes: Which Is Right for Buyers in Idaho Falls and Logan?

If you’re ready to build a home in Idaho Falls or Logan, you’ve likely come across two popular options: custom homes and production homes. Each offers unique benefits, and understanding the difference can help you make the best decision for your lifestyle, timeline, and budget.

At Kartchner Homes, we build high-quality production homes with thoughtful included features and a simplified process designed for today’s buyers. But we also understand that some families may be considering the custom route. So, let’s break down the difference between custom and production homes—and how to choose what’s right for you.


What Is a Custom Home?

A custom home is built entirely to your specifications—from the floor plan to the finishes. You’ll typically work with an architect and a custom home builder to create something one-of-a-kind. This option gives you maximum control over your home’s layout, style, and materials.

Pros of Custom Homes:

  • Full design control
  • Unique floor plans
  • Tailored to specific land or lot conditions

Cons of Custom Homes:

  • Longer timelines (often 12+ months)
  • Higher costs, especially if changes are made during construction
  • Requires more involvement and decision-making from the buyer

What Is a Production Home?

A production home, also called a spec home or pre-designed home, is built from a library of professionally designed floor plans. These homes are crafted with efficiency and value in mind. Buyers often choose from curated design options, and many homes are already under construction or move-in ready.

At Kartchner Homes, we offer personalized selection builds, giving you the ability to choose colors and finishes from a range of beautiful options without the overwhelm of starting from scratch.

Pros of Production Homes:

  • Faster build times
  • More affordable pricing
  • Streamlined process with fewer decisions required
  • High-quality included features and finishes
  • Often available as move-in-ready homes

Cons of Production Homes:

  • Limited floor plan customization
  • Fewer structural changes allowed

Which Is Better for Idaho Falls and Logan Buyers?

If you’re building in Idaho Falls or Logan, a production home is often the most practical, efficient, and affordable choice especially for growing families, first-time buyers, or anyone looking to move in sooner rather than later.

Why Kartchner Homes Stands Out in Idaho Falls and Logan:

  • We build in the most sought-after neighborhoods with nearby schools, parks, and amenities.
  • Our homes feature superior included features—so you don’t have to pay extra for quality.
  • We offer both move-in-ready and personalized selection options, giving you flexibility without the custom home headaches.
  • We’re local builders who care! Our team knows Cache Valley and Southeastern Idaho because we live and work here too.

Final Thoughts: Custom vs. Production Homes

The choice between a custom home and a production home comes down to your goals. If you want a one-of-a-kind design and are prepared for a longer, more expensive process, a custom home may be for you. But if you’re looking for value, speed, and quality, a production home from Kartchner Homes in Idaho Falls or Logan is a smart and reliable choice.

Ready to explore your options?
Contact Kartchner Homes today to tour our available homes or start your personalized build journey.